SHEET 02.05
SCALE — AS NOTED
DRAWN & WRITTEN INDEPENDENTLY
THE PERMANENT WAY
TRACK · ROUTES · RULES · RECORDS
NO TIMETABLES
NO TICKETS
NO AFFILIATION
Great JourneysSheet 02.052 min read

The Night Train, and Why It Keeps Coming Back

The economics that killed it and the ones bringing it back.

By the Permanent Way · Great Journeys · 2 min read
The Night Train, and Why It Keeps Coming Back
Plate 01 — The economics that killed it and the ones bringing it back.

Cheap aviation and high-speed rail buried the overnight train. Different forces from those that killed it are now arguing for its return.

Section 01The arithmetic that lost

For roughly thirty years after the low-cost airline arrived in Europe, the sleeper train was a category in decline. The logic was hard to argue with: a budget flight was faster and often cheaper than a couchette, and high-speed day services had already eaten the medium-distance overnight market. Operators cut routes; rolling stock aged and wasn't replaced. By the early 2010s, even state railways with sentimental attachments to the format were running down their fleets.

~2016Year ÖBB relaunched and rebranded Nightjet services

On routes where a flight takes ninety minutes, there was simply no competitive case.

The economics were real. A sleeper train ties up an expensive path on a busy network all night, runs at slower average speeds than the daytime expresses sharing that network, and requires specialist rolling stock — berths, fold-down beds, end-of-car washrooms — that costs more to build and maintain than an ordinary coach. Revenue per seat-kilometre is lower than a daytime express. On routes where a flight takes ninety minutes, there was simply no competitive case.

Stone railway viaduct crossing a wide valley
Plate 02 — a stone railway viaduct crossing a valley. The engineering that makes a route worth the fare.

Section 02The arithmetic that returned

What changed was not the railway. It was the accounting around aviation. As carbon pricing entered European policy discussion, and as airports became genuinely unpleasant experiences rather than neutral inconveniences, the overnight train acquired a new kind of value it had never needed to claim before: it departs from a city centre, arrives at another, and the journey time is time you were asleep anyway.

Data plate — the four journeys · Plate 03

RouteDistanceDaysTime zonesHighest point
Trans-Siberian9,289 km781,040 m
The Ghan2,979 km31700 m
Settle–Carlisle117 km11356 m
Flåm Line20 km11866 m

Austrian Federal Railways relaunched Nightjet services from around 2016, expanding to routes connecting Vienna, Amsterdam, Brussels, Paris and points across central Europe. Other operators followed or announced intentions. The format — private compartment, couchette, or seated — had not meaningfully changed since the 1970s. The argument for it had.

There is also a network effect that is only now being rediscovered: an overnight connection stitches together city pairs that no sensible high-speed line will ever link directly, because the distances are too great or the populations at each end too small. Siberia, Norway, parts of Australia — long-distance night trains survive in exactly these geographies, where the alternative is not a flight but no service at all.

Cross-references

The night train's revival in Europe is modest, fragile and dependent on political will over pure commercial logic. But the arithmetic is tighter than it was. That, for a format that has been written off several times already, is enough to keep the lights on.

Distances are route kilometres, not great-circle. Days are end to end with no stops off. Highest point is the summit on the through route.

HOW THIS SECTION MEASURES
DISTANCE — ROUTE KILOMETRES
DAYS — END TO END, NO STOPS OFF
HIGHEST POINT — ON THE THROUGH ROUTE
MAPS — REAL GEODATA, NEVER HAND-DRAWN

Referenced on this sheet

Referenced

ÖBB (Austrian Federal Railways)

Austrian national rail operator; relaunched Nightjet sleeper network

Referenced

Siberia, Norway, Australia

geographies where long-distance night trains survive by necessity

Related sheets

Previous in Great Journeys
← Crossing a Continent With Almost Nobody On It
Next in Great Journeys
Last sheet in the section